[This message was delivered on 11.10.24 at Central Presbyterian Church, Geneseo NY, based on Mark 12:38-44. A video of it can found on that church’s webpage.]
You invite me to preach here for the first time on the Sunday after All Saints Sunday and the Sunday before your stewardship Sunday with dedication of the pledges for 2025. I feel the weight of it. You invite me to preach here for the first time on a Sunday in which the lectionary gospel text is about some not so good scribes and a poor widow who gives her last two cents to the temple treasury where the not so good scribes work. I feel the weight of it. I am reminded of a story of a pastor that announced to the congregation one fine Sunday, perhaps in November during stewardship season: “I have here in my hands four sermons: a $10,000 sermon that lasts five minutes; a $5,000 sermon that lasts fifteen minutes, a $1,000 sermon that lasts a full hour; and a penny sermon that lasts till noon. Now, we’ll take the collection before the sermon, have it counted while we sing a hymn, and see which one you want.”
This is no easy assignment. At the end of it you may want me to go back a week and join the heavenly company of all the saints. Or you may want me to come back next Sunday, not as your preacher, but as the main course for the stewardship lunch. Serving roast preacher might increase the pledges!
I love this passage, but not in a simple, easy way. There is an edge to it, an ouch to anyone who might be a religious leader, like me. It gives us two short sections, not easily related, except both feature religious leaders and both mention widows. Those leaders were called scribes. They were educated; they could read and write, which made them somewhat elite. They studied the Torah, the written law of God, which we call the Old Testament or Hebrew scriptures. They wore white robes, which commanded respect from the faithful and set them a step or two higher than most people. Hence, I am wearing my white alb this morning. Anyone could have worn white this morning and anyone could have worn a white robe. But you didn’t and I did. When I put this on, shortly before worship, I am reminded that I am a person under orders. I have studied scripture long and carefully and have earned some degrees. And therein is a danger. Religious leaders can be dangerous. Ask Jesus. I don’t want to be the kind of scribe Jesus describes.
Jesus is pretty harsh on scribes. He often pairs them with the Pharisees. The scribes and Pharisees of Jesus’ time knew God’s law backwards and forwards, but in most cases they were devoid of love and grace. They loved their lofty status. As this passage notes, they took advantage of widows and loved to be in places of authority. They said long prayers to be seen and heard by the people they were to serve, with no regard for the God they were supposed to be loving and serving. They were the ultimate religious leaders and they gave religion an exceedingly bad name. We still have scribes around today, people, usually men, that twist religion from something beautiful into something ugly. There are church leaders today that live in palatial homes, drive the most expensive cars, and even have their own jet planes. I am sympathetic to the millions of people today that say they are spiritual but not religious. I am sympathetic to millions of people today that say they like Jesus, but have no interest in church, in organized religion. I have worked for the Church, for organized religion, most of my adult life—and I am often somewhere between disappointed and troubled by the Church, by organized religion. Instead of being so organized, I wish we were more organically authentic. Instead of being so right about our doctrines, I wish we were more righteous in the pursuit of justice for the downtrodden. I do not want to be known as scribe, but as a sinner saved by grace, a wandering lamb that has been returned to the fold by the Good Shepherd.
Jesus said to his disciples, “Beware of the scribes, who like to walk around in long robes and to be greeted with respect in the marketplaces and to have the best seats in the synagogues and places of honor at banquets!They devour widows’ houses and for the sake of appearance say long prayers. They will receive the greater condemnation.” Ouch.
In some ways, that is the easier part of this passage. Part two sounds great at first, then gets too close for comfort for a solidly middle-class citizen like me. The setting seems to be the Temple in Jerusalem, since Mark sets this squarely in what we call Holy Week, the week that culminates in the betrayal, suffering, and crucifixion of our Lord. Knowing that will add to its gut punch. The Temple was like a great cathedral set in the center of the city. It was easy to observe people coming and going and honoring religious rituals. Think of St. Patrick’s Cathedral on Fifth Avenue in the heart of New York City. When my daughters were young, we usually made an early December shopping trip to the city, visiting the tree in Rockefeller Center and the windows of the department stores on Fifth Avenue. We would look forward to stepping into St. Patrick’s Cathedral, sitting for a while, and watching people come in to pray, light candles, cross themselves, and genuflect. In addition to a few minutes of rest, I found it moving to see people in this crazy, bustling city coming in to express their faith in acts of devotion. And there were collection boxes near where candles were lit and by the entrances. They weren’t charging admission, but receiving gifts of gratitude. I might even reach into my pocket and pull out some loose change and maybe a few small bills and drop them into those collection boxes as an act of gratitude for this magnificent cathedral plucked down right into the heart of the city.
Now we have a picture of Jesus entering the Temple courts with his disciples and sitting down for a few minutes of quiet rest. Jesus sees rich people putting in large gifts. He makes no comment, no judgment. He just watches this parade of scattered people. Then he sees a poor widow enter. How does he know she is a poor widow? He could tell, as we likely could. Widows had a tough lot back then. There was no social safety net. They were dependent on having some living relatives, ideally a son or two, with the means to support them, to take them in. If they didn’t have some living relatives, ideally a son or two, with the means to support them, to take them in, they were usually destitute, consigned to begging and finding some kind of shelter for sleep, as the homeless do today. The temple courtyards provided such a place.
Jesus fixes his attention on her. She humbly approaches the collection box. She clutches two little coins in one hand. How does Jesus know there are two coins? Because he is watching intently and anyone listening could hear two coins bouncing in the collection box. Jesus calls his disciples close to him and puts the spotlight on a poor unnamed widow. Look at her, he says. She gets it. She sets the pace for the economy of generosity. Her humble gift far exceeds the showy large gifts that represent no sacrifice, no love, no gratitude, no heart.
Now listen to this passage, both parts, from “The Message,” a popular paraphrase of the Bible: He continued teaching. “Watch out for the religion scholars. They love to walk around in academic gowns, preening in the radiance of public flattery, basking in prominent positions, sitting at the head table at every church function. And all the time they are exploiting the weak and helpless. The longer their prayers, the worse they get. But they’ll pay for it in the end.” Sitting across from the offering box, he was observing how the crowd tossed money in for the collection. Many of the rich were making large contributions. One poor widow came up and put in two small coins—a measly two cents. Jesus called his disciples over and said, “The truth is that this poor widow gave more to the collection than all the others put together. All the others gave what they’ll never miss; she gave extravagantly what she couldn’t afford—she gave her all.”
In just a few days in Mark’s gospel, Jesus will give his own two small copper coins, his very life, to God. His hands will be unclenched by large spikes. He will hold nothing back. At the end of her sermon on this passage, Barbara Brown Taylor, one of my favorite preachers, gives us this assignment. Sit down somewhere where people are coming and going. Watch quietly. Look for the people on the edges, the ones it would be easy to overlook. Not the leaders with their white flowing robes, or tailored suits, or the latest fashions. Crunch your eyes and look and ask, “Where is Jesus in this picture?” Could it be that Jesus comes to us in the guise of a poor unnamed widow?
